The IR35 legislation is riddled with grey areas, which naturally leads to misinformation and misunderstandings. Perhaps one of the biggest areas of confusion is surrounding personal service and substitution.
Most contractors will have heard of the ‘right of substitution’, but many will not truly understand what it means and how it can potentially be used to your advantage.
Firstly the explanation:
If there is an IR35 enquiry HMRC will be trying to ascertain whether the particular engagement is genuinely business to business in nature, or if it is simply disguised employment.
The contractor should have been engaged as a business, not an individual, and the skills required to do the work are the company’s – not the individual’s. Therefore, as long as the services can be carried out satisfactorily, the contractor’s company should be able to send whichever representatives it sees fit.
Of course, the likelihood is that the contractor is the only person in the company who can do the work, but what must exist is a ‘right of substitution’. It is vital that this right is in the written contract and even more important that it exists in reality.
The key question is this:
If you were unable to provide the services for a period of time (a day, a week – not necessarily a long time) and you had a suitable replacement with all the same skills, qualifications and vetting/clearances, would you be able to send them in your place?
The end user could satisfy themselves that the replacement was suitable, but they should not be able to reject a substitute on unreasonable grounds. The contractor’s limited company must be responsible for paying the substitute and remain responsible for the successful completion of the services.
In reality it is unlikely that you would ever genuinely need to exercise this right, BUT if you ever do get the opportunity to send someone else it is well worth considering. In effect it would win your case before it had started; substitution carries so much weight that HMRC wouldn’t have a leg to stand on if you proved that you had actually sent a replacement.
Indeed, ‘actual substitution’ is worth 20 points on their Business Entity Tests, which would immediately put you in the ‘low risk’ category. HMRC have stated that if, in the event of an enquiry, a contractor proves that they are ‘low risk’, HMRC will close the investigation down and won’t touch you again for 3 years.
So if you know any contractors who work in a similar area (they can’t be at the same client unfortunately) and you think your end client would be amenable to accepting a replacement, it’s certainly something to consider.
If you want to learn more about our IR35 accounting services, please contact us today!
More Blogs
How Much Should You Set Aside for Tax as a Sole Trader?
Unlike employees, sole traders do not have tax deducted at source. There is no employer calculating PAYE, no automatic deduction for National Insurance, and no reminder each month that part of your income is not really yours. Instead, tax builds up quietly in the background until a large bill arrives – the tax year AFTER the income was earned. This article therefore explains why it is essential for sole traders to set aside sufficient funds for tax, and how you can estimate a “safe” amount to put aside during the year. It is written for UK sole traders and focuses on Income Tax, National Insurance, Payments on Account, and the upcoming changes under Making Tax Digital.
How will the 2025 Autumn Budget Impact My Business?
This article examines how the recent 2025 Budget announced by the Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves will impact small owner managed businesses.
How Do Pensions Work and What Tax Relief is Available?
This article briefly explains how pensions work, the main types of schemes available, and the tax advantages that accompany them.